Goatie Whites Fleischmanns
Goatie Whites Logo

Goatie Whites

@

4.5738 reviews

Goatie Whites offers a unique dining experience in the heart of Fleischmanns. This pizzeria and bar serves fresh seafood, tasty American grill dishes, and delightful desserts. Locals love the casual vibe and friendly service. The spacious terrace invites guests to enjoy their meals outdoors.

With an extensive menu, there’s something for everyone. Whether it's a quick bite or a relaxed dining experience, Goatie Whites fits the bill. Make sure to check out their ice cream selection; it's a hit on warm days. Enjoy the lively atmosphere, especially during events like trivia nights.

About

Located at 46 Depot St, Goatie Whites is surrounded by the scenic views of the Catskill Mountains. The restaurant has become a beloved spot for visitors and locals alike. It balances a fun atmosphere with delicious food, perfect for families and groups.

The building reflects the charm of the area, combined with modern touches. It offers a cozy fireplace to warm up during winter. The restaurant operates with access in mind, featuring facilities that accommodate all guests. It’s not just about food but also about community.

Regular live music events create a vibrant dining atmosphere. Enjoy outdoor seating while soaking up the beautiful landscape. Goatie Whites comes to life as a gathering spot for friends, food enthusiasts, and those seeking memorable moments.

Get in Touch

46 Depot St, Fleischmanns, NY 12430, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday Closed
  • Wednesday 16:00-21:00
  • Thursday 16:00-21:00
  • Friday 16:00-21:00
  • Saturday 16:00-21:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Personnel tres gentil et aimable. Service rapide comme d'habitude aux states. Par contre, la nourriture n'est pas des meilleures. Le steak ou on a demande bleu etait trop cuit. La pizza Margherita beaucoup trop ecoeurante. Tres (trop) large choix de plats. On y trouve pour toutes les envies. Comme beaucoup de restaurants ici, tout ferme tot."

- Lac M.

"1/15/25 first time here w/my instructor friend. Cool spot. Friendly staff. We had dinner in the bar area. I had the chicken parm hero. It was really good and i took half home with me. I also took home the bread, because my friend didn't eat it and i wanted to try it. Well, let me tell you, 250f for 4 minutes in my air fryer (on toast) and it was perfect!! So get the bread and eat it. Good beer selection on tap and in bottles & cans. I look forward to returning."

- dave I.

"Excellent service despite the busy place! We didn't participate but really enjoyed listening in on the trivia night! It was awesome. The food was delicious. The place has dessert galore so save room for dessert! This place is great! I highly recommend this place if you need to find a place to eat in the area!!"

- Marion N.

"Casual and fun. Lively diners and staff. Great for a local ski town restaurant. Menu prices are very reasonable and portion sizes were good. Enjoyed my medium pizza pie where I was allowed to customize half / half with toppings. The broccoli and cheddar potato skins were good. All it needs is bacon (I'm sure you can ask but it was not listed on the menu). The baked haddock with crabmeat stuffing was a hit. Pass on the chicken burrito, while plenty of chicken, it was too shredded for my liking. And there was only cheese on the top... Wish there was more. Desserts were great, even to go. We got chocolate dipped strawberries, baklava, and assorted brownies. Very good value. There's a general store too if you want to support local businesses."

- Jeannie T.

"Was staying in Margaretville and looked for a good ice cream/dessert spot for me and my travel partner. We're so happy we made the short drive to Goatie Whites. The view from their porch is breathtaking for a city person like myself. The ice cream was excellent and they had one of the greatest donuts I've ever eaten in my life. We wished we had went sooner so we could go again!"

- Scott F.

"We has the best ice cream.. with the best price !"

- stephannnie s.

"Great local spot. Food was great. You can get donuts for the morning, fudge for later and great ice cream."

- Debbie M.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visit Goatie Whites for its impressive menu filled with local specialties. The pizza is especially popular. Customize it just the way you like. For seafood lovers, the baked haddock is a must-try, packed with flavors.

They offer a fantastic selection of desserts too. The homemade ice cream is creamy and delicious, perfect for summer days. Friendly staff enhances the dining experience, ensuring speedy service even when busy.

Trivia nights bring in crowds and create a lively atmosphere. Join in or simply enjoy the buzz. Reservations are accepted, making it easier to dine at peak times. Families appreciate the kid-friendly menu and high chairs available for little ones.

The warm ambiance attracts various groups, from tourists to locals. The terrace offers a scenic view, enhancing your meal experience. Whether it’s a casual lunch or dinner with friends, Goatie Whites caters to all.

Most Liked things

The lively atmosphere draws diners back again and again. Many rave about the pizza quality. Excellent brews on tap add to the energy of the place. Desserts are another highlight, particularly the homemade options like brownies and ice cream. Lots of shareable small plates offer variety.

Most Disliked things

Some diners mention inconsistent food quality. Orders for certain dishes, like steak, have been a hit or miss. A few find the extensive menu a bit overwhelming. Busy nights can lead to longer wait times. Some seek a more refined dining experience rather than a casual setting.

FAQ

What are the must-try dishes at Goatie Whites?

You must try the shrimp scampi over pasta and BBQ ribs with French fries. Don't miss the garlic knots either, they are a crowd favorite.

Is Goatie Whites family-friendly?

Yes! Goatie Whites offers a kids menu and a relaxed atmosphere. It's perfect for families looking to enjoy a meal together.

What dining options are available?

Goatie Whites provides dine-in, takeout, and delivery. There is also an outdoor terrace to enjoy your food in good weather.

What drinks can I find at Goatie Whites?

The bar has a great selection. Enjoy options like bourbon, scotch, or specialty drinks. Don't miss their hot specialty drinks, perfect for a cozy evening.